The Lovely Bride vs. KMC
Quite normally in years past the Lovely Bride and I have BOTH often pulled for the same American Idol as they wove their way through the weeks of competition.
This year's class of contestants is so very good from a talent perspective that we are finding ourselves increasingly at odds over who we are pulling for.
I will tell you - it's difficult not to love the Lovely Bride's choice - Brook White, because on overall passion, spirit, enthusiasm, and personality it is doubtful there has been a more likable person on the show in its history.
But is she the best singer? Is she even the best musician?
In terms of musicianship - I think that David Cook can go toe to toe with her. In terms of raw vocal passion - Michael Johns is ever bit the passionate performer she is. In terms of vocal range Syesha Mercado and Carly Smithson both have her beat.
But that darn grin is so hard not to pull for.
Last night I think we saw Remiele give her swan song. DialIdol
has the science of the busy signal and they seem to indicate the same thing.
I voted for the third week in a row for Syesha. I didn't even really like her in the early weeks!
BUT...
She's proven she has the biggest voice in the competition. She's got the biggest range, broadest appeal, and she too has a fun personality.
Brooke may be the all-American girl next door, but Syesha IS the best singer left in the contest... and this IS a singing competition...
Isn't it?