What's Hot | Search |

Get Your Personal
On-Air Report Here

blog advertisingis good for you
Monday, November 12, 2007
Posted by: Kevin McCullough at 10:12 PM

In case you missed it I addressed my heavy hearted concerns about some of the heavy handed tactics being taken by Romney critics. The prominent ones in particular...

If you missed the column, here it is: Romney Critics: NOT telling the whole story!

One of those - and a nice guy at that - Brian Camenker wrote to respond to my encouragement to at least present both sides.

His response:

Dear Kevin,

I enjoyed your article on Romney, Sandy Rios, Gregg Jackson, and me.
However, there are a few points you might note:

(1) I don't find Romney's opinion on a federal Marriage Amendment very important because, constitutionally, the President has no part in the amendment process. Only Congress and the state legislatures affect it.

(2) In 2002 when there was a solid Marriage Amendment being proposed in Massachusetts, Romney refused to support it because (he told the Boston Globe) it didn't allow for civil unions. He later supported a "soft" amendment that did not ban civil unions.

(3) After Romney's "conversion" on abortion, he signed into his "universal health care" bill that gives us public funded abortions and puts Planned Parenthood in an official advisory capacity.

(4) I am not an evangelical Christian. I am Jewish.

Best regards,
Brian Camenker

It's truly interesting that on the notes that Camenker wishes that I would "note" he falls guilty of the very same thing the original column discussed - CONTEXT. Let's go through them one at a time.

(1.) Support of the Marriage amendment is irrelevant to this critic in particular because he can't pass it? Such an odd thing to say given that there wouldn't even be a federal marriage amendment had the PRESENT President not consistently fought to get it into Congress. The next President will have at minimum the same ability as the current President to rally support, pressure lawmakers and speak of the need to pass such legislation.

(2.) Words like "solid" and "soft" are very big gaps in this criticism. To be more specific - Romney did not support the version of the state marriage law that used the term civil union as well as marriage. Would I have liked him to - sure. But it is also reasonable to argue that civil unions (not homosexual in nature) are of need in our society. (A dying parent allowing their child to form a civil union with them to operate bank accounts, manage money, oversea medical care - is not a pipedream - but a reality for thousands of Americans. Such "civil unions" are done with two individuals and an attorney. This also goes to demonstrate why homosexual "civil unions" are so unneccesary - they already - AND have already existed.) My battle is for the term, idea, and institution of marriage being a unique and seperate entity that we as a society protect. This concept and literal understanding is the same concept that Mitt Romney espouses. Camenker, Rios, and Jackson can not prove otherwise...

(3.) On abortion is Mitt where I am on 0% abortions being allowed under the law? No. Therefore his mandating the health insurance issue in his state to outlaw all abortions was unrealistic. In Mitt's case he believes they should be outlawed 99.97% of the time. (Only exceptions - mother's health, rape, and incest. Again the exact same position as our current president - THE MOST PRO-LIFE PRESIDENT in history.)

(4.) I DO APOLOGIZE for misrepresenting Camenker's faith. It was an oversight. The time's he had been on my show - he spoke with such fervor for the righteousness of our nation - I made a bad judgement call. Though the Jewish faith cares equally as much about TRUTH as Biblical Christianity does - therefore the principle I was arguing stands strong!

To date, I have not yet heard from Sandy Rios or Gregg Jackson, but will be glad to post their responses - in the interest of as much transparency as possible. (Something the three of them - have yet to afford the former Governor.)



View in ascending order View in descending order
Sign Up to Post Your Comments Sign Up to Post Your Comments
Please take a few seconds to sign up, then you’ll be able to post your comments immediately, use the action center, get podcasts, create your own blog and more! If you are already registered, click here.
Note: Fields marked with a red asterisk (*) are required.
Salutation:
First Name:
*
Last Name:
*
Email:
*
Address 1:
*
Address 2:
City:
*
State:
*
Zip:
*
 

 

blog advertising is good for you
Archives
Blog Search:




Blogroll
PREMIUM BLOGS
Andrew Sullivan
BatesLine
Ben Shapiro
Beyond The News
Blogs For Bush
BlueStateConservatives
Broken Masterpieces
Captain's Quarters
Cheese and Crackers
Communists For Kerry
The Corner (NRO)
Daou Report
David Limbaugh
Dawn Patrol
EasonGate
Filling Up Space
Fire Ant Gazette
Front Page Magazine
GOP Bloggers
Happy Husband
HillaryWatch
Hugh Hewitt
Instapundit
John Huang
Kaus Files
Kevin McCullough
Kerry Spot
LaShawn Barber's Corner
Lileks
Little Green Footballs
MarriageWatch
Michelle Malkin
Northshore Politics
Obama Factor
Pardon My English
Powerline
Rabes Ramblings
Radio Blogger
Ramblings Journal
Ray Pritchard
Real Clear Politics
Red State
Saint Kansas
Scrappleface
Sexless In The City
SlantPoint
Townhall C-Log
Volokh Conspiracy
Vox Popoli
Weintraub
WizBANG
Worldthreats
Zorn's Notebook

CPAC BLOGS
Ace of Spades HQ
Alarming News
Ankle Biting Pundits
GOP Bloggers
HughHewitt.com
JunkYardBlog
Kevin McCullough
La Shawn Barber's Corner
Miscellaneous Objections
Outside The Beltway
Politics from Left to Right
Redstate
Terrorism Unveiled
The American Mind
The National Debate
TheAgitator.com
Townhall.com
Winds of Change.NET
Wizbang
Wonkette


GODBLOGGERS
Adrian Warnock
Al Mohler
Better Living
Ethos
Evangelical Outpost
It Takes A Church
John Mark Reynolds
La Shawn Barber
Mark D. Roberts
Normal Rockstar
Ray Pritchard
Rhett Smith
Roman Catholic Blog
Stand to Reason
Steve Camp
Stones Cry Out
Summa Aesthetica
The Anchoress

MILBLOGGERS
Argghhh!
Austin Bay
Belmont Club
Black Five
Centcom
Counterterrorism Blog
Froggy Ruminations
Hooah
Howdy
Hurl
Law and Ordnance
Major K
Mudville Gazette
Smash
Training for Eternity